SkilletGuy

Borough Furnace Skillet 10.5" vs Butter Pat Fry Pan 12inch

Updated January 2026 • Cast Iron Comparison

Quick Verdict

Our pick: Borough Furnace Skillet 10.5" wins for higher user ratings. Both are excellent choices, but the Borough Furnace Skillet 10.5" edges out in overall value.

Borough Furnace Skillet 10.5"

Borough Furnace

$280-$300

4.8/5 (320 reviews)

Pros

  • Artisan quality
  • Unique design

Cons

  • Very expensive
Check Price

Butter Pat Fry Pan 12inch

Butter Pat

$66-$76

4.3/5 (17,079 reviews)

Pros

  • Excellent heat retention
  • Easy to maintain
  • Oven safe
  • Made in USA

Cons

  • Learning curve
  • Not dishwasher safe
Check Price

Feature Comparison

Feature Borough Furnace Skillet 10.5" Butter Pat Fry Pan 12inch
Price Range $280-$300 $66-$76
Brand Borough Furnace Butter Pat
User Rating 4.8/5 4.3/5
Review Count 320 17,079

Who Should Buy Each?

Choose Borough Furnace Skillet 10.5" if:

You're looking for collectors.

Choose Butter Pat Fry Pan 12inch if:

You're looking for baking cornbread, everyday cooking.